They say April showers bring May flowers… but maybe it’s time they bring a decision about your bathroom: walk-in shower vs tub?
Should I keep my bathtub… or finally upgrade to a walk-in shower?
If you’ve been staring at your old tub wondering if it’s time for a switch, this guide is for you. We’re breaking down the pros, cons, and key considerations to help you make the best choice for your space, your lifestyle, and your goals.
🛁 The Case for Keeping Your Bathtub
Let’s give the tub some love. While walk-in showers are trending, bathtubs still offer real value in the right situations.
👍 Bathtubs are great if:
- You have young kids or pets — nothing beats bath time for wrangling toddlers (or muddy paws).
- You love a good soak after a long day.
- You’re in a neighborhood where families buy — having at least one tub could make your home more marketable.
According to This Old House, even older homes can modernize without sacrificing charm — especially when the remodel is done with long-term functionality in mind.
But let’s be honest… when was the last time you actually used your tub?
🚿 Why Walk-In Showers Are Taking Over
Walk-in showers have become one of the most popular upgrades for homeowners — and for good reason.
✅ Benefits of walk-in showers:
- Easier access — no high ledge to step over
- Modern, open design — makes even small bathrooms feel bigger
- Easier to clean — fewer corners, no grimy grout lines
- Better for aging in place — especially with grab bars and slip-resistant flooring
- More customizable — built-in niches, sleek surrounds, and fixtures that fit your vibe
And let’s not forget:
HomeView’s walk-in showers are made with a high-tech polymer base — a nonporous, mold-resistant surface that won’t crack, chip, or stain over time. It’s the upgrade you can count on every day.
👉 Explore walk-in shower styles from HomeView
⚖️ Walk-In Shower vs Tub: How to Choose What’s Right for You
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. But here’s how to think it through:
🏡 Your lifestyle:
- Do you actually take baths?
- Is your bathroom part of your daily recharge or a get-in-get-out zone?
📏 Your space:
- Smaller bathrooms benefit big-time from walk-in showers
- But if you’ve got a spacious primary suite, a freestanding tub might still work
👪 Your household:
- Have small kids? Might want to keep one tub somewhere
- Living alone or aging in place? Showers are safer, easier, smarter
💸 Your resale goals:
- Some markets expect at least one tub
- But modern buyers are prioritizing style, safety, and low-maintenance living
Not sure what today’s buyers really want? This guide from Better Homes & Gardens breaks down key resale considerations before you ditch the tub.
Need a guide? That’s what we’re here for!
🧼 HomeView’s Custom Shower Solutions
We specialize in more than just style — our walk-in showers are designed for real-life performance.
High-tech polymer base – crack-resistant, easy to clean, no mold- Custom-fit installs – seamless look, minimal disruption
- Optional safety features – grab bars, benches, low-threshold entry
- Fast, professional installation – no weeks-long bathroom chaos
This isn’t a cookie-cutter home store remodel — it’s a personalized upgrade that matches your needs.
❓ FAQs
Q: Does removing my tub hurt resale value?
A: Not always. In family-focused markets, having one tub can help. But in modern remodels, buyers love walk-in showers — especially with accessibility features.
Q: Can I put a walk-in shower in a small bathroom?
A: Absolutely. In fact, walk-in showers are perfect for maximizing space and improving flow.
Q: What’s the cost difference between the two?
A: Walk-in showers may cost more upfront, but they often pay off in value, safety, and maintenance.
Q: Are walk-in showers safe for seniors?
A: Yes! Especially with slip-resistant bases, grab bars, and bench options — all of which we offer at HomeView.
Walk-in showers are also highlighted by AARP as one of the most impactful upgrades for aging in place — especially when paired with grab bars and slip-resistant flooring.
📆 Ready to Make the Switch?
Whether you’re ready to ditch the tub or just exploring your options, we’re here to help.
Our team at HomeView USA will walk you through:
- Layout ideas
- Safe and stylish upgrades
- Financing options
- Fast installation timelines
👉 Request your free, no-pressure quote
⚡ TL;DR Quick Summary
Not sure whether to keep your tub or upgrade to a walk-in shower?
Walk-ins offer safety, style, and everyday convenience — while tubs hold nostalgic value and work well for families.
The best choice? The one that works for you — and HomeView is here to make it happen.